As a student of the Liberal Arts, I have always wondered at the primogenial splendour of the Greek sciences. In the epoch of ground-breaking discoveries Plato lived in, the embryonic forms of the great disciplines were not so specifically defined and exclusive as they are nowadays. By consequence of its primitivity, Greek culture was more of a unified whole than a fragmented universe of isolated crafts. This makes the Greek world that much more appealing a place to start from for the scholarly study of humankind's cultural heritage: its holistic perspectives, in which Theology and Philosophy have repercussions in the practical sciences as much as the other way around, constitute a refreshing break from our messy and confusing post-modern climate of alienation.
The Speech of Eryximachus is a good example of the Greek's holistic approach to reasoning. Combining notions of philosophy and medicine, Eryximachus' praise of Love illustrates the kind of inclusive treatment all things deemed worthy of elaborate discussion were likely to receive by the Greek intellectual elite. Eryximachus also borrows freely from other thinkers of his time to strengthen his position. The following lecture will first attempt to (1) explain the Speech of Eryximachus' place in the unfolding of the Symposium. The second focus will be (2) to provide a summary of Eryximachus' main ideas. Thirdly and lastly, (3) the various implicit and explicit references to prominent figures of Greek culture, such as Hippocrates and Heracleitus, will receive some attention.
The Place of the Speech of Eryximachus in the Symposium
The fourth portion of the Symposium doesn't stand out for the singularity of the opinions it presents; like the Speech of Pausanias before it, the Speech of Eryximachus builds on earlier propositions. Eryximachus does not properly dispute the conclusions of either Phaedrus or Pausanias but rather progresses in the same direction, contributing to the discussion by refining the definition of Love with references to his own field of expertise. Thought it seems that, by the time of Aristophanes' turn to speak, the matters of divinity have been pretty much dealt with, the Speech or Eryximachus doesn't break from the themes previously discussed by Phaedrus and Pausanias. The discourse proceeds almost linearly, with the shift of the prominent theme from the more general one of Greek myth to that of medical science operated very subtly so as to not loose the already established context. One can envision many possible motives that would justify this approach. It could be observed, for example, that the speeches of Phaedrus and Pausanias were part of the few speeches regarded as deserving preservation amongst the other non-recounted ones, like we read in 178a:
"Aristodemus did not quite remember all of what each of them said, nor do I in turn remember everything that he said; but I'll tell you what he especially remembered in the speech of each, and which seemed to me worthy of mention"
Keeping that statement in mind, it is not difficult to understand why the author would not like a discontinuity to belittle the importance of these speeches in the sequence of things. A sudden shift in the focus of the discourse could lead the readers to distance their attention from the previous contents. Any rough-edged change of the prevalent theme is therefore avoided by introducing the Speech of Eryximachus with a commentary on the previous speech. Although Eryximachus' speech shares the same objective as the two earlier ones, that is, the praise of Love, it also has a very different essence. While Eryximachus' criticism is probably honest, it seems that passage 186a serves more the function of connecting the rest of Eryximachus' speech to earlier parts of the Symposium than any intrinsic purpose. Considering a similar process is used in the Speech of Pausanias even though the two first speeches are very similar with regards to their content and concern, it seems legitimate to note that Plato's care in contextualizing is substantial.
Furthermore, the Speech of Eryximachus, with its numerous references to Love as a state of health achieved through the harmonizing of opposites foreshadows Aristophanes' discussion of the origin of Love. In the following part of the Symposium, Aristophanes will take up Eryximachus' understanding of harmony and translate it into the notion of Love as reconciliation in his comical retelling of the story of Ephialtes and Ossus. We observe again a sense of continuity in the gradual change of themes, although perhaps this time the shift is not so subtle as in the beginning of the Speech of Eryximachus. Arguably, concerns regarding harmonious context are no longer so crucial as earlier on in the Symposium. As three speeches have already solidly established Plato's approach to the subject, to flatten the thematic fluctuations any further could only make the text boring.
The content of the Speech of Eryximachus
That is enough about the place of the Speech of Eryximachus in the Symposium; the content of the speech itself is much more interesting as it contains a number of problematic statements. Eryximachus starts his speech by claiming that Eros is universal and therefore not exclusively a matter of interpersonal relationships. Indeed, Eryximachus defines Love more as a natural force than a psycho-social phenomenon. Eryximachus retains Pausanias' distinction of the two types of Love, with other consequences however: one Love is made into the urges of the diseased; the other into the desires of the healthy. According to Eryximachus, health is also the result of (good) Love, which effects a reconciliation of opposites. From this, we may or may not choose to infer that the other sort of Love is a cause of disorder. One problem that arises is the ambiguous and confusing explanation of the causal relationship between Love, health and harmony of opposites. It seems as if Love might be at once that which establishes the Harmony and the Harmony itself. In 186d, we read:
"He who knows how to instill Eros where it is not present but ought to be, and to remove it where it is and ought not to be, is the good practitioner: for it is necessary to be able to make the most inimical elements in the body friendly and love each other. But the most inimical are the most opposite: cold to hot, bitter to sweet, dry to wet, all such as that; it is by knowing how to instill Eros and unanimity that our progenitor Asclepios, as these poets here say and I myself believe, established our art."
The conclusions of the first and the second sentence seem to constitute a contradiction, in which case it becomes rather difficult to nail down the identity of either Loves. A compromise would be to understand good healthy Love as a reconciling factor and Harmony of opposites as its expression. A look at the pre-Socratic tradition of speculative philosophy would give more credit to this later interpretation. Empedocles, for instance, understood Love to be a unifying force; were it not for its opposite power, commonly referred to as Strife, the universe would not be divided into the things we may observe. This is the notion of philia: Love as the principle of Attractiveness. Using this definition could help make more sense out of the first sentence, which could be rewritten as follows:
"He who knows how to instill Attraction where it is not present but ought to be, and to remove it where it is and ought not to be [and thus divide the things that ought to be divided], is the good practitioner: for it is necessary to be able to make the most inimical elements in the body friendly and love each other."
Still, this notion does not help with the second sentence, not anymore than with the end of the first.
But let us now move on to other parts of this speech. From 187a to 187e inclusively, Eryximachus fancies himself a musician and makes a very loose reading of Heracleitus' statement:
"They do not understand how being at variance with itself, it is drawn together with itself: a back stretched (or backward turning) attunement, like a bow or a lyre"
Eryximachus fails to grasp what Heracleitus really means here: to illustrate a paradox, that things may be in harmony at their utmost degree of opposition and strain. In fact, Eryximachus' own words (translated in English) are: "(…) it is utterly absurd to say that attunement is at variance, or derives from things still at variance". This statement is, to say the least, a bit disconcerting, first because it mercilessly and hastily dismisses Heracleitus' challenging theory on the grounds that it is apparently contradictory. This is a mistake; if Heracleitus uses this metaphor, it is precisely to express what could otherwise seem contradictory. More than just helpful references, the bow and the lyre constitute observable evidence of Heracleitus' point. Another problem with Eryximachus rapid dismissal and reinterpretation of Heracleitus's statement is that he has made a very similar argument only a few lines earlier in his depiction of the role of Eros in the health of the human body, in the form of the following statement "It is necessary (…) to make the most inimical elements in the body friendly and to love each other". It seems unlikely that these elements should lose their character of opposition, which is essential to their nature, by whatever process of reconciliation is intended here.
Eryximachus then progresses to make a lengthy metaphor describing Love as the Music of existence. He argues that so long as something is at variance it can never be attuned. Here, it may seems as if he is mistaking metaphor for truth, and it is also very much unclear - even to me, and I'm a Music Major - what precisely he is getting at. Is Eryximachus saying that dissonant pitches and unequal rhythm sound… well… dissonant and unequal? So it is the task of music to make these things agree; nonetheless, music only works with polar opposites: high and low, fast and slow. In this case, the legitimate conclusion would be that in Music, Love is the relationship of harmonious chords and proper rhythm, an abstraction which, once isolated, is difficult to grasp, even for musicians. Much like shape, harmony is an emergent property; to attempt to imagine harmony detached from sound is much like trying to imagine shape without that which is shaped. In any case, all these allusions to music help very little to our precise understanding of Love.
Education and culture is the next subject to deserve Eryximachus' attention. Using again notions of harmony, Eryximachus proclaims that it is in the way of Love to gratify orderly men and to urge disorderly men into becoming orderly. The definition of Love becomes gradually more vague, almost so far as to be confused with the Good, as Eryximachus presents the general disciplines of life, warns to beware of the Vulgar Eros and urges us to opt for the better kind in all of their exercises . In no instance does he provide a detailed explanation of what each Love represents in these fields of activity; rather, he only mentions their consequence.
In sum, and notwithstanding its vast population of bugbears, we can draw at least one conclusion from the Speech of Eryximachus. It is spelled out in the very first paragraph of his speech: Love is not strictly a matter of interpersonal relationships. The rest of the speech, although it fails to express the detailed significance and repercussions of this statement very efficiently and eloquently, provides numerous examples of where Love, agreement or attunement, exists as a non-human phenomenon.
As observed earlier, Plato lived in inspired times: it is only natural that we be interested to know more about Eryximachus' inspirers so that we may understand his reasoning more fully. Foremost of these figures is Heracleitus of Ephesus: now, he was already discussed in this presentation, so I will not extrapolate a great deal more on his philosophies. I will only point out that Plato did not hold Heracleitus in very high esteem. With a ruthless approach to their rivals' views, both Plato and Aristotle considered him as a radical and a poor logician; neither were ready to grant him the benefit of doubt in the form of a more lenient interpretation of his philosophy. Heracleitus probably did not mean that things cannot have enduring identities; rather, it seems like he wanted to point out the importance of Flux (or Change) in the ultimate, underlying order of things. That Nature is always in a state of Flux does not necessarily entail that there can be no higher order - indeed, a river's "riverness" depends on the changing of the waters, just like our continuing existence depends in great part on the movement of our atoms.
Heracleitus was not alone to view change as a factor of existence of prime importance: Anaximander, for example, observed in the working of the world a sort of cycle:
"Whence things have their origin,
Thence also their destruction happens,
As is the order of things;
For they execute the sentence upon one another
- The condemnation for the crime -
In conformity with the ordinance of Time."
One interpretation of the sole remaining fragment of this philosopher's work understands the seasons as the result of this cycle, not unlike in 188a of the Speech of Eryximachus.
Furthermore, Heracleitus' understanding of Flux lead to important developments in later philosophy. We recognize its influence in the teachings Empedocles, of which sadly little original text have survived down to our time. In Empedocles, the universe is in a state of constant change and conflict as philia (Attraction) and neikos (Strife) unite and divide the four elements, Hot, Cold, Wet and Dry. Again, in this system, the change of seasons, like all other natural phenomena, is attributed to varying degrees of philia and neikos, with direct influence on the elements. While this is reminiscent of Eryximachus position on the role of Love in nature, it is also perhaps a bit more articulate than what Eryximachus had to suggest, especially considering it is rather unclear how exactly the good and the bad/Vulgar Love effect changes on physical conditions. The point here, however, is to note that the notion of Love as a natural Force was not uncommon; Eryximachus was probably exposed to a number of cosmological systems in which on sort of Love or another played a central role.
Another important philosopher which Eryximachus refers to, and this one almost ad nauseam, is Hippocrates of Cos. Hippocrates was the founder of the Hippocratic tradition of medicine from which modern medicine is often said to be descended (rightly or wrongly is another issue altogether). We find in Hippocrates' teachings a synthesis of the Heracleitean notion of the balance of opposites and the Empedoclean elemental system. According to the theory of the four humours, blood, phlegm, black bile and yellow bile were the elemental constituent of our bodies, and health the result of an harmonious balance of all these substances. In Hippocratic Medicine, it was generally thought that a condition called for an opposite cure, that is, that depletion was to be cured with filling, fullness with emptying, exertion with rest, atrophy with action, etc. This kind of discourse imbues the Speech of Eryximachus so evidently I do not think it necessary to supply any specific reference.
Though the Speech of Eryximachus certainly presents some difficulties, it is also remarkable for the variety of topics it cover, from Greek religion to meteorology. Clearly, Eryximachus is neither a great philosopher nor a good Renaissance man: nonetheless, by providing us with such a wide array of interesting references to the Greek arts, his speech is perfect to spark discussion. There is so much to say in response to Eryximachus' discourse, so much research involved in circumscribing his field of references, that such study is a valuable exercise indeed for all students of the Greek World.


No comments
Post a Comment