Pages

Wednesday, 4 February 2004


Did you celebrate on Groundhog Day? If not, maybe it's because you are not aware February 2nd is a date charged with spiritual power. Pagan traditions around the world hold festivals on this day. In the Celtic tradition, it is called Imbolic and Oilmac: as the cold shadows release their their grip little by little; it is time to anticipate the return of the bright days.



The early Christian Church also recognized this day as sacred: on the night of Candlemas, the feast of Lumen Vitae (the Light of Life), the priest would walk up the alley with a single candle, chanting as the faithful gave thanks for the return of life and light to the land. Gradually, more candles would be lit until finally the whole church became a sanctuary of luminance.



Don't miss it next year!

As for myself my twenties hit like a plague of locusts. Perhaps this is quarter-life crisis.





THE SECOND LETTER OF PAUL TO THE THESSALONIANS



A seminar presentation given by Etienne Domingue on Candlemas 2004






1. Introduction

The significance of the works of the apostle Paul is well known to every New-Testament reader. Along with St Luke's Book of Acts, the Pauline epistles constitute a wealth of information on the formation, initial functioning and beliefs of the early Christian Church. While 2 Thessalonians is probably not the most important text of this tradition (it is, after all, the third smallest section of the entire Bible) it does clarify crucial points of Christian eschatology.



2. Context of Thessalonians 1 and 2

In all likelihood, Thessalonians 1 and 2 were written at a few months interval, during Paul's second missionary journey, which began shortly after the Council of Jerusalem, in 50 C.E. After being chased from Thessalonica where he had just established a new Christian community, Paul was relieved to learn from Timothy that the faith of his new converts remained strong despite persecutions. He thus proceeded to write a long and heartfelt letter of praise and encouragement, that is, 1 Thessalonians, urging his former disciples to remain steadfast in their convictions. 2 Thessalonians was composed soon thereafter, presumably in response to certain news of the Thessalonians which reported a misinterpretation of Paul's message. The main focus of 2 Thessalonians is to rectify Pauline doctrine, emphasizing that the Second Coming was not, in fact, at hand.



As no writing from Paul's first missionary journey were ever discovered to this day, Thessalonians 1 and 2 are quite probably his earliest epistles.



Who was Paul at this stage?

When Paul wrote to the Thessalonians, it is safe to say he had fully internalised the founding notions of Christianity. By then a man in his early fifties, Paul had been converted for almost 20 years, and done a great deal of missionary work. It should not be reflected, however, that the apostle's Jewish background did not influence his writing. Indeed, Paul's erudite knowledge of both Jewish law and lore is well represented in his epistles, notably by his concerns for right teaching and eschatology. Acts 17 recounts that Paul debated with the Jews of Thessalonica for three Sabbaths in a row, in a typically Pharisaic fashion. We can therefore establish with relative certainty that, at this time, Paul was knowledgeable in both religious traditions. Furthermore, as a Roman Citizen of Tarsus in Cilicia, Paul was evidently acquainted with Hellenistic culture. All in all, Paul must have been very much a man of his time, by no means a cultural outcast or a philistine.



Who were the Thessalonians?

Located in the very heart of the Hellenistic world, Thessalonica was in Paul's time the capital of the Roman province of Macedon, the homeland of Alexander the Great . According to Acts 17, there was a synagogue there, indicating the presence of a significant Jewish community. It seems, however, that Paul was more successful with Thessalonica's Gentile population than with its Jews. Still according to the Book of Acts: "Some of them [Jews] were persuaded and joined Paul and Silas, as did a great many of the devout Greeks and not a few of the leading women. " (17.4). Members of the early Christian community in Thessalonica must have been mainly Gentile men and women. As Paul had to flee after only three weeks of proselytising and training new converts, it is not difficult to imagine how fragile the fledgling Church must have been, especially in these troubled times.



3. Content of 2 Thessalonians

Form, structure and message

2 Thessalonians doesn't particularly stand out for its originality: it follows the typical structure of the other Pauline letters, moving from greetings (1.1-2) to a short thanksgiving section (1.3-12), onward to the actual body of the letter (chapter 2 ) , to the paraenesis (3.6-12), and then to a brief conclusion (3.16-18). In essence, 2 Thessalonians is a warning against the perversions of Christian doctrines proclaiming the direct imminence of the Second Coming; virtually all of its parts are harmoniously oriented to convey that message. The thanksgiving section stresses the notion of destiny, divine will and right belief; that the early Christians in Thessalonica are in fact chosen, and will reap their reward in the world to come. It isn't very hard to see how this part contributes to the whole, notably by setting the tone for the rest of the letter, insisting on the positive attitude of other Churches towards the Thessalonians as the product of their persistence and orthodoxy. Subsequently, the body of the letter warns against possible attempts at leading the community astray with counterfeit material ( "by spirit or by word or by letter, as though from us" (2.2)). From there it proceeds to provide the correct doctrine by elaborating on the concept of the false prophet and other premonitory signs of the Last Days. The paraenesis advises the Christian community of Thessalonica to remain faithful to the Christian doctrines elaborated earlier on, and to distrust antagonistic views. Emphasis is placed on the evil of idleness: men and women are not to cease their daily work in expectation of divine deliverance, or to adopt a lifestyle of begging and live off unearned goods, for while they were in Thessalonica the Christian proselytisers did not do those things. Up to the conclusion, all the parts of the text serve the same purpose; directly or indirectly, they are all criticising deviant practices.



Comparison with 1 Thessalonians

While 2 Thessalonians is significantly shorter than 1 Thessalonians, and consequently, makes considerably fewer points, the two texts still bear important similarities. For instance, the beginning of their respective thanksgiving sections are, suspiciously enough, almost identical. On the other hand, we find in the second letter no lengthy panegyric , no distracting circumvolutions. The author seems much less enthusiastic and more straightforward, progressing linearly in the discussion of his single topic. Two additional similarities are found in 1 Thessalonians: on 2.9 when the author stresses the importance of hard work, and more generally in the 5th chapter, when he addresses the question of eschatology; both these positions are reiterated in greater detail in 2 Thessalonians.



The authenticity of 2 Thessalonians

2 Thessalonians' flagrant literary resemblances with 1 Thessalonians have lead many modern exegetes and other scholars to believe 2 Thessalonians is really a forgery. While, to the modern reader, it would appear unseemly to write twice the same opening for two letters to the same recipients, one must always keep in mind that epistles were more than mere correspondences. These similarities could very well be the expression of Paul's concern for the respect of a certain literary form, or else an attempt to maintain a kind of consistency. Indeed, it could be that 2 Thessalonians otherwise suspicious beginning was in fact intended to increase its credibility as an authoritative text, its resemblance with 1 Thessalonians somehow consisting a proof of Paul's authorship. All of this is in the realm of sheer speculation, as there is no sure way to know. Forgery or not, 2 Thessalonians does not contradict 1 Thessalonians, but rather complements it.



4. Conclusion

Review of the main points

In a few words, 2 Thessalonians would best be summarized by this verse: "Brothers and sisters, do not be weary in doing what is right." (3.13) that is to say: be persistent in your orthodoxy. 2 Thessalonians is primarily a warning against deviance, elucidating key notions of eschatology and reiterating certain ethical positions regarding Christian lifestyle in expectation of the Second Coming.



Sources: The New Catholic Encyclopaedia, The New Advent Catholic Encyclopaedia Online, The New Revised Standard Edition.



The role of 2 Thessalonians today

In fact, regardless of its actual authenticity, 2 Thessalonians provides a good overall picture of the New Testament approach to eschatology which is much more approachable than Revelation.





No comments

Post a Comment