Pages

Wednesday, 24 September 2003


A class discussion on True Love.



Disclaimer: This is not an essay.



TRUE LOVE

(whether it waits or not, and what does it constitute)

by Nwar





Truth is a whisper and only a choice.

-John Rzeznik



Initially I had thought to respond to the question of True Love with scoffing irony, but I then remembered the profound dislike of cynicism apparent in this community. With all due respect, it seems to me that few have been exposed to alternative methods of thinking which involve a good deal of creative destruction and proceed, as it were, by stripping the mind of its fetters. We will recognize this as wisdom from the mouth of Socrates, but we are no better than the Athenians when we find ourselves in the same state of perplexity as the one the Philosopher was so famous for. We'd much rather the voice of dissent shut up, and to achieve this end, Academia can be just as efficient as any concoction of hemlock.



But I digress. No discussion on the notion of True Love could be complete without first establishing a working definition of Truth and Love. One will admit that both terms are at best ambiguous, if not downright hopelessly confusing. I should be a happy camper if I could simply avoid the problem by directly disputing the efficiency of all languages, but that would be the coward's way out. Therefore, let us first address Truth.



May I repeat my opening quote? Truth is a whisper and only a choice. I will suggest this definition of Truth: that it is a value we attribute to the things we deem to be the most urgent, intense or even sometimes absolute, as no thing is any truer than another with regards to its existence in phenomenal reality in another popular sense of the word. This other possible understanding of Truth is synonymous with Reality or Thingness; in this case it would make no sense to speak of varying levels of Truth, nor even of unTruth, as a logical consequence of this definition would have it that if a thing has at some point come into existence, as a configuration of matter or ideas, it is then, by nature, true. Yes, in this sense my hat is true and forever will be, even long after I will have passed away, for its existence echoes in time as a part of the progress of things, as the movement of its atoms and the eventual dissolution of its current unity. Still in this sense of the word which I shall not be using, that a thing is passed, present, future or even (arguably) mere unactualized potential, doesn't make it any less true.



Thus let us move on to the definition of Truth I wish to work with: the value which we attribute to things we deem the most important, obviously with a purpose in mind. Like a whisper, it is intangible, ungraspable, and personal. In this definition, the element of choice is crucial, for random things do not become important without anyone to perceive them as such, and the commonsensical judgement to make is that it is us, with all of our intelligence or consciousness (or not, as the case may be) who take the decision to attribute them such personal importance. Note how my hat is so much more incredibly important to me than it is to you. In this sense it is then, for me at least, a True hat.



Now the matter of Love. I choose to understand the engaging impulses of "appreciation" of someone or something - both loving and liking, the terms merely indicate varying degrees of granted importance - as one of the elementary components of our individual personality, the atoms of our identity. Aside from the idea that we behave in order to enter the state which we love/like the most, we can find little else to justify our actions. I do not mean to portray human nature as egotistical, but the fact is: should one have high hopes for world peace and act accordingly, these aspirations are only justified inasmuch as one loves them. Only the madmen, nay, probably not even they, would ever seek unwanted ends for the sake of unwanted ends, and that's hardly possible logically.



Therefore Truth is a measure of importance we give to certain things, while Love is the cause and motivation of our actions, the search of good ends. It should necessarily follow that True Love is for each person the most important of all her/his motivations, that one thing she/he would give up last should the whole of reality suddenly collapse.



Now, had I more room to extrapolate on this topic, I should provide more arguments and examples to back up my position… Although my position is really not a statement of what I hold to be true - such a standing would, as it were, absorb the premises and go full circle. Rather, it is but a suggestion of an alternative perspective. I would also like to speak more of what I think should be the best True Love, or more accurately, of what I think we ought best to truly love in order to lead more fulfilled existence. As a teaser, I could say that I do not believe the best True Love can be achieved through interpersonal relationships, although those could certainly be an expression of it. This view is not inconsistent with the arguments developed earlier as it's really much more a matter of objectives than of means. Therefore it is possible for one to truly love (perchance unwittingly?) less fulfilling things (or people) and that love would still be as True as any other, truth being (at least in this suggested system) but a choice.

No comments

Post a Comment