PART I
Eros has never grown a beard.
Hakim Bey, CHAOS: The Broadsheet of Ontological Anarchy.
Le coeur à ses raisons que la raison ignore.
Blaise Pascale.
While human relationships can be approached rationally, it cannot be denied that an ungraspable non-rational element has an important influence on interpersonal behaviour and mentality. Whether this component, desire or Eros, is merely and just the consequence of our primarily animal nature or the result of a greater metaphysical power is subject to debate. In any case, Eros is as immanent a fact of existence as Logos or even Life, and from a strictly human perspective it is difficult to conceive of a universe in which these three could have manifested each other independently.
Aristotle has demonstrated well enough in his Nicomachean Ethics how there can be rational means and ends to friendships. In book VIII, we read:
"There are therefore three kinds of friendships, equal in number to the things that are lovable; for with respect to each there is a mutual and recognized love [philia ], and those who love each other wish well to each other in that respect in which they love one another. Now those who love each other for their utility do not love each other for themselves but in virtue of some good which they get from each other. So too with those who love themselves for the sake of pleasure; it is not for their character that men love ready-witted people, but because they find them pleasant. Therefore those who love for the sake of utility love for the sake of what is good for themselves, and those who love for the sake of pleasure do so for the sake of what is pleasant to themselves." (VIII:III)
In his definitions of utilitarian and sybaritic friendships, Aristotle articulates the notion of a teleological approach to interpersonal relationships. Human beings can, and indeed often do, engage in a relationship on rational grounds with a more or less definite purpose in mind. What motivates this kind of friendship can be easily understood in rational terms: satisfaction of a given need, hopes for a better future, etc. We see clearly how these kinds of interactions, although sensible and legitimate, do not represent ends in themselves: in this sense, they do not constitute a valid example of Eros, this idea of an abstract, transcending desire for a thing (or person) for that thing's (or person's) sake. Aristotle makes a clear distinction between the pleasure and/or utility-oriented friendships and the Perfect friendship, which has to do with something more than strictly apprehensible ends.
"Perfect friendship is the friendship of men who are good, and alike in virtue; for these wish well alike to each other qua good, and they are good themselves. Now those who wish well to their friends for their sake are most truly friends; for they do this by reason of own nature and not incidentally; therefore their friendship lasts as long as they are good- and goodness is an enduring thing." (VIII:III)
The purpose of the Perfect friendship is therefore the ultimate purpose, that is, the reciprocal Good - for the befriended and in the person of the befriended. While Aristotle works on further defining the Good, in both the genial Nichomachean Ethics and in his other works, everything ultimately boils down to this foundational aspect the aretaic ethics system: we ought to do Good simply because that's what we ought to do. This is the point where further logical analysis becomes impossible.
In fact, it seems like a society in which all friendships were based strictly on reasoned purposes (other than the sufficiently elusive Good) could not endure. In John Swift Gulliver's Travels, we read about the Houyhnhnms, a race of horses gifted with absolute, unfailing rationality. When Gulliver ends up stranded on their island following a mutiny, he is forced to acknowledge all of his human flaws and quickly attributes them to lack of reason. While this moralistic tale is indeed endearing, it does not recognize that any mode of existence relying strictly on the comprehensible is doomed to failure, mainly because there always comes an end to understanding. Compared to the potential infinity of things ungraspable and unknown, our finite reason doesn't weigh heavy: we must therefore accept the non-logical if we are to commune with each other and with the universe. With no appreciation of a simple, intrinsic Good (for which there would be no room in a purely logical and pragmatic social structure) there would be no force, no ideal to motivate survival and proliferation. It doesn't seem like a universe reduced to an equation would allow for a significance enhanced-lifestyle.


No comments
Post a Comment