Read on the back of a MAPP (Mild Artistic Propaganda Print) I'm dropping in a teacher's mailbox (like a bomb, but not as loud):
"We are encultured beings.
We don’t choose our culture.
I disagree. An exalted perspective allows for a choice of position regarding the cultural matrix provided by the environment. The choice of what each individual makes of the data supplied by the cultural milieu may or may not be entirely free; there’s plenty of room for debate there. More importantly, however (and this is my point) our individual cultural constructs are so unique, so radically different from one another, that it becomes hard to elaborate any serious and convincing argument in favour of the thesis of ultimate cultural predetermination.
We are Greeks.
I disagree. Though I think this may have been true for the intelligentsia two or three generations ago, it seems to me like there has been too much cultural hybridisation to proclaim that our modern perspectives originate especially from the Greek heritage. Has not progress reshaped the body of our popular norms significantly enough to call it predominantly a mongrel? Isn’t that part of the message behind Post-Modernism? By stating this I mean to undermine neither the value nor the importance of the Greek’s legacy, but only to highlight the importance of the new media and their significant impact on both the Western and the Eastern world. We have noticed in the past few years that the young intellectual elite show signs of an intense impulse to transcend the restrictions heaved upon themselves by their past… A desire that could not have been fulfilled before this epoch, a time in which access to the necessary information is omnipresent. Our era has also found a way to provide space for this revolution in the form of the global cultures ( like WWW culture) in which the frontiers of space and the prejudices of normality (like limiting social standards) are abolished.
I’m perfectly certain this is going to be an interesting semester. I look forward to it.
.senegoiD evol od I hguoht ,esnes taht ni ton ,cinyc a ton ma I"
This teacher also has a rather strange and ambiguous notion of Logos. This is especially unfortunate because I already have mine, and it's very definite, concrete and (guess what?) actually in accordance with what most authorities out there have to say (notably Merriam Webster:
Main Entry: Lo·gos
Pronunciation: 'lO-"gäs, -"gOs
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural Lo·goi /-"goi/
Etymology: Greek, speech, word, reason -- more at LEGEND
Date: 1587
1 : the divine wisdom manifest in the creation, government, and redemption of the world and often identified with the second person of the Trinity
2 : reason that in ancient Greek philosophy is the controlling principle in the universe)
It seems to me that my teacher (who shall remain unnamed) has failed to outline critical aspects of the Logos: first, its independent, external existence as an abstraction (which we find expressed in what mostly everyone has to write on Plato) and its pseudo-divine nature in even the less hermetic cosmologies. In this sense isn't Logos more of a Force, as in, the world's super-intelligence?
In any case, the idea of Logos shouldn't be confused with the Dao. Neither should it be confused with the finite mind of men as these two concepts are fundamentally different in classical philosophy, the former being inscrutable and incorporeal and the latter (arguably) incarnate. The problem here (from my perspective) is that my teacher has been talking about individual logoi in terms of degree, without establishing any explicit distinction from the Logos… His example was that to capture a fish, one needs to integrate its logos… that human logos is better than animal logos. This is definitely a creative interpretation of the word logos, but what has it got to do with the Logos? Limiting one's definition of Logos to "reason" is a bad move. Adding a semi-mystical taste to it by blurring up the boundaries and talking in mushy metaphysical terms doesn't help.
L'esprit de contradiction reviens en force.
Tomorrow I have a discussion on "what is religion". Fun fun fun. I think some LaVey is in order.
Homework: More reading than I could ever have dreamed of.
Tune du jour: Time Served by Dispatch, and also Vivaldi's Autumn.


No comments
Post a Comment