Une affiche d'art pour le concert de l'université Bishop's de Lennoxville: O Fortuna
A comment on my last post, in response to Jackson's comment (because it got truncated by Haloscan):
I don't think any of the three statements were argumentatively interdependant. Furthermore, I am not the author of this comment: Thom Yorke (Radiohead's lead singer) is. The whole paragraph is a link to a website concerning the band's activism.
I agree in part with each of the statements when approached individually:
-The American government has lied.
=Weapons of mass destruction are yet to be found on Iraqi territory. While the more-than-probable absence of such weapons does not delegitimizes overthrowing Hussein's brutal dictatorship,there remains the sad fact that Bush as deceived a nation. Two, actually, if you count U.K., though U.K.'s population was never really fooled: only its leaders were, and they blatantly ignored the will of the masses.
-We have the right to call them liars.
=As far as we know, Bush and Blair have lied concerning evidences of weapons of mass destruction. Either that, or they were misinformed, in which case I'm not sure what exactly is the more concerning. At the time where popular support for the war was at its highest, false information and prejudices were widespread worldwide. Polls indicated that a majority of Americans believed Iraqi terrorists were aboard the planes that destroyed the WTC, which is, of course, not the case. Iraq before the War on Terrorism, although a ruthless dictatorship,was certainly amongst the countries in which Islam's influence was the more contained, at least in the Arabic world. Neither the governments nor the mainstream media attempted to change any hateful beliefs.
-They are putting our children's future in jeopardy
-They are not controlling the terrorism threat, they are escalating it.
=By overthrowing Saddam the Americans have weakened Iraq's frontiers,leaving the coast clear for terrorist groups such as Al Qaeda. In a country where popular morals lie in ruins after considerable civilian losses, there's no telling what underground movements can do.
Furthermore, the humiliations caused by all this violence are unlikely to deter extreme Muslims to turn back on the cause of Islam. On the contrary; the people who have already lost everything will see the War on Terrorism as an opportunity for martyrdom. The Q'ran promises direct access to heaven to martyrs. Islam is the fastest growing faith in the world, and currently the second largest. I need not conclude or further explicate my syllogism.
We have seen Afghanistan revert to chaos and the steady increase of violence in even the least "fundamentalist" powers of the Arabic world: Turkey, Tunisia,Morocco.. The War on Terrorism has spread on too many fronts; the only thing safe to say is that no place is secure. In a political climate such as today's, we cannot afford a total war... and yet the World's top superpower has openly engaged itself in a hopeless conflict.
I'll finish with a quote:
"Every gun that is made, every warship launched, every rocket fired
signifies, in the final sense, a theft from those who are hungry and
are not fed, those who are cold and are not clothed. The world in
arms is not spending money alone. It is spending the sweat of its
laborers, the genius of its scientists, the hopes of its children.
This is not a way of life at all, in any true sense. Under the cloud
of threatening war is humanity hanging from a cross of iron."
- Dwight Eisenhower


No comments
Post a Comment