Pages

Sunday, 7 December 2003


By Jove, these people are not even kidding: Chick's fundamentalist tracts. Fortunately, these ones are: Chick parodies.



This Chick person is so wrong I think it's important to spend time addressing the issue.



-First of all, what is his rejection of Catholicism based on? A few non-essential principles of the movement's liturgy. The core teachings of Catholicism are the same as in the other great movements of Christianity. It is non-sensical for one sect of any religion to condemn all of another sect's philosophies and dogmas: for the faithful, this would amount to contradicting oneself.



- Chick accuses Muslims everywhere of moon-god worship. Personally, I have no problem with lunar spirituality and I engage in it on a regular basis. On the other hand, I can definitely understand why the followers of Islam should feel offended by this gross oversimplification of their belief-system.



There is evidence that, anciently, the Ka'bah was populated with a number of pagan idols: prior to Muhammad's reformation, the Arabs were largely polytheistic. While it is possible to trace back the cult of Allah to a certain moon deity of the pre-Islamic Arabic pantheon, this doesn't disqualify or delegitimize Islam's strict monotheism. Islam and the current understanding of Allah is very different from the original Arabic religions.



Besides, in all likelihood, the cult of YHWH too is descended from some older polytheistic religion. Traces of polytheism abound in Christianity: the Angels (especially the order of the Seraphim) are almost undeniably related to the Zoroastrian yazatas. The Cherubim, far from the tiny putti we're accustomed to see in Renaissance Art, were originally immense winged bulls, very popular in Achaemenid architecture. It is clear that the very notion of Messiah has evolved away from its initial meaning ("anointed one") which referred to just about any rightful king of Israel and intended no divine nature or parentage. The movement of Messianic Judaism out of which Christianity emerged understood the Messiah in terms awkwardly similar to the Zoroastrian's: as a Saviour descended from Heaven. The same notion took shape very early in Zoroastrianism's eschatology: before the end of days, the Saoshyant, third of a series of three superhuman religious leaders, is supposed to come visit the earth and establish forevermore the rule of Ahura Mazda, the God of Good and Light. In sum, it would make no sense to elevate Christianity above the other monotheistic faiths because of the "originality" of its "One-God". In my opinion, if "originality" of a religion's principles was a standard for judging its validity, Australian Primordial Monotheism would be way up there on the top, and Christianity (at best a mongrel) would be far, far below.



-According to Chick, it looks like Paganism is all about summoning supernatural entities to effect changes on one's surroundings. That's not the case. In my experience, neo-Pagans are monotheists, or perhaps more accurately, monists: they believe in a transcending yet also immanent entity, the source of all life and sentience. The different Gods and Goddesses of the Ancient pantheons are understood to be merely aspects of this one Deity. Not unlike what we find in Hinduism, the archetypes (idols) of Wicca and other neo-Pagan faiths point to some superior reality, both within and beyond the faithful. Rituals and Magic do not call for anything outside of reality: that would be impossible. While spirits (the creatures of some non-material world) are indeed invoked, these are no more than guides, helpers or teachers, not totally unlike mortals. Now why should there be anything impious in requesting assistance to achieve a better understanding of the Supreme Reality and further develop one's respect of Life and Nature?






Now for some radicalism:

I've got to hear more of the Box Car Satans!

No comments

Post a Comment