Pages

Thursday, 5 August 2004









Trois Principes Clés du Monde Occulte

dans l'ordre approprié,


I.

Le Principe du Chaos


Que la Création est fondée sur le Chaos (Tohu) ; que toutes notions d'Ordre et de système ne reposent que sur les observations faillibles des consciences temporales. Que l'Existence est d'abord et avant tout inscrutable et imprévisible.



II.

Le Principe de la Banalité

Que toutes choses en toutes circonstances tendent naturellement à préserver leur caractère ordinaire et routinier.



III.

Le Principe de l'Échelle de Jacob


Que le Pouvoir d'un individu augmente proportionnellement avec sa susceptibilité de rencontrer des gens et des esprits de Pouvoir - et vice versa - pour le meilleur ou pour le pire.









I'd e-mail the authors of this anti-Christian website if only their commenting form was working.



Greetings,

I stumbled on your site looking for (St) John Chrysostom's opinion on the religious practices of early Christian women. Though I must admit your erudite radicalism is refreshing & challenging, I think the case should be made that your website does not present enough of the brighter side of the Abrahamic Faiths.



Throughout history, the pretext of righteous observance of Judaism, Christianity or Islam has caused much unnecessary bloodshed. Doctrine & dogma have too often justified religious & temporal elites in their opportunistic endeavours. On the other hand, these very religious traditions have also provided the motivation for great moral achievements & salutary societal cohesion in difficult times. Your website would have more intellectual impact if it made more room for discussion on the manner in which religion's negative aspects outweigh such positive points.



And what of religion as a psychological phenomenon in the development of civilizations? It has been remarked that, for all of the World's cultures, religions have served as proto-science - providing a cosmology & fundaments of metaphysics. Are we then to heap scorn on humankind's first attempts at understanding the universe - that noble enterprise - simply because these philosophies have been supplanted by more efficient systems & models? For this reason I would recommend that the question of whether or not Religion has outlived its strictly utilitarian purpose be posed more sincerely.



The aesthetic quality of Religion, also, would need to be assessed more explicitly. For even post-modern Western culture stems out of a Judaeo-Christian context: the two earliest Abrahamic Faiths have so affected the evolution of civilizations it is impossible not to see traces of their influence everywhere around us. We as Westerners cannot, in a manner of speaking, despise everything Jewish or Christian without acknowledging serious fault with ourselves. Though this judgement would seem entirely legitimate at face value, pushing it to the extreme would amount to some kind of neurotic anti-narcissism. In the same breath we should curse all of the fields of human activity, especially the Arts & the Sciences, for there are none that have not been severely influenced by at least one notorious Jew, Christian or Moslem.



Also, positive elaboration on alternatives to religion would be much appreciated. Out of concern for fairness, the monsters of secularism (Maoist China & its genocide of intellectuals, for example) should also be exposed amongst the many more examples of how civilizations can go wrong.



To conclude with what I consider to be the most important point my critique of atheism in general (& of your website in particular): the whole is not equal to the sum of its parts. A consistent treatment of religious traditions is inappropriate with regards to the inconsistent nature of religions. Nay, I dare say it is inadequate in the light of the inconsistent nature of human behaviour itself. If the World's religions succeed in simultaneously embodying the best & the worst of humankind, certainly the phenomenon deserves more insightful treatment than plain rationalistic sleight of hand.



Most sincerely,

Etienne D. Polygnostic,

Ontological Anarchist & student in Religion & Music









Leçon du Jour: One should never repeat words spoken in anger.

Furthemore, never say: "I am above you, pain." For those who are so transcended never boast in such a way.






No comments

Post a Comment