. . .
This constitutes excellent material for an exposé on why Religion scholarship is important:
"Jesus came into our world "at the fullness of time" (Gal. 4:4). Universally speaking, at the moment of Jesus' birth, everything dove-tailed in human history. There was a unified Hellenistic culture, a single language for commerce (Koine Greek), a stable political system controlled by the pragmatic Romans, a fine highway network, etc. Also a highly-developed religious system existed in Palestine (which had originally come from God). However, this Jewish hierarchy had been transformed by Satan into a very powerful religious machine (Pharisaism) which was poised to kill Jesus. In a sense, Jesus could not be born until the Pharisees and others like them had reached their zenith (Gal. 4:4). Deity incarnate had come to earth to confront incarnate institutional religion head-on! And, they could NOT coexist. The stage was set."
Let's take two minutes to see how wrong this is; an interpretation of Scripture based strictly in Scripture, and with only superficial understanding of Scripture's historical context, leads to grave errors in judgement and Faith.
Koine Greek was a lingua franca, but like all linguae francae, it is difficult to establish how much consensus it brought about. The Modern World has a new lingua franca: English. Does this testify to the Modern world's stability? Far from it. The growing influence of a domineering cultural matrix has been responded to with harsh criticism and even acts of violence. Think September 11.
It would be naïve to think the ways of power have changed very much in the past 2000 years. True, the Empire provided some stability, but Palestine has been has been a thorn in the side of tyrants throughout its long history. The Holy Land never condescended to put on a single face. Judaism was far from a unified organization around the time of Christ - the debate between Pharisees, Sadduccees, Samaritans, Therapeutae and ascetic orders, as testified by several ancient authors, was very lively. In his lifetime, Josephus was affiliated with as much as three different Jewish factions, and he admits himself that the division between various interest groups is what ultimately caused Judaea's defeat. That the Temple fell is proof, on one hand, that the Jews were too divided to put together a successful resistance, and on the other hand, that the Romans did not deal with the radicals so as to sustain a climate of stability.
Pharisaic authority in the time of Herod must have been limited at best; it is well known that the Sanhedrin had little influence under autocratic rulers. Since when do aristocrats like to share their dominion with senates? Not only was it Herod who held the reigns of government, but even his authority was dwarfed by the belligerent Roman force, which constantly exerted pressures on Israel.
As for Sanhedrin hierarchy, we have very little informations has to how it worked, and whether it was run by a Pharisaic or Sadduccean majority at the time of Jesus is difficult to discern.
But it is not enough to question what kind of authority the Pharisees had; it is also necessary that we look at what type of doctrine they advocated. Pharisaic Judaism, as far as we can deduce for Scriptural and extra-Scriptural evidence, was not the legal and theological system of the elite but rather the product of centuries of reflexion on morals and holy living, born out of a concern for bringing religious observance within the reach of the common people and out of the Temple precincts. The Pharisees, like Christ, were reformers. Not only that, but they preceded Him with regards to some of His teachings. Rabbi Hillel formulated the Golden Rule long before Christ.
As for Pharisaic persecution of Christians? It was a matter of survival. In the Roman World, Judaism was religio licitas; its heresies, however, were not - and Christianity happened to be just one of them. What boorish anti-Semites fail to understand is that stamping out heresy is not only a means by which orthodoxy is maintained for orthodoxy's sake, it is also the only way to uphold a certain definition of religiosity over and against others, which is required to maintain a credible identity. Had Judaism suddenly begun to harbour too many contradictions - had it become the embodiment of even more of the variety to which Roman standards were already opposed - it would certainly have lost the modicum of Roman respect it had, and this would have meant its doom. Saul the Pharisee was zealous in his violent dealings with his future brethren, but there is no reason to believe that he was the standard.
And don't get me started on Jewish Christianity! Jewish Christianity makes sense as the Jewish followers of a Jewish Massiach. Gentile Christianity, on the other hand, is some kind of monster, a gigantic error of history - a freak of contradictions. It prevailed through some inconceivable happenstance, and took centuries to homegenize its teachings into a consistent creed. If anything, Gentile Christianity is the first instance of the institutionalization of a religion divorced from its integral religious precepts within the Abrahamic faiths. Never prior to (or even perhaps after) the evolution of the Church would there be a similar distinction between the tradition of authority and interpretation and the tradition of "Revelation" or original substance of the Faith (in this case, the Hebrew Bible and the New Testament). Christianity, first and foremost, is a new paradigm superimposed on old ways, whereas Judaism at the time of Christ was for the most part a systematized body of rather literal interpretations of Ancient texts. This is not a value judgement, but a clarification of terms: in matters of degrees of institutionalization, Christianity Ancient and Modern is at least as institutionalized as its Pharisaic predecessor, if not more so, and certainly in a much more atificial manner. Christianity's emphasis on metaphor and transcendance is a testimony to the abstraction of its teachings from its Scripture.
The point of this being: an ignorant grasp of Biblical concepts will lead to erroneous ideas and intolerant views which desecrate the Scriptural message. The opinions voiced by The Examiner logically leads to a devaluation of Pharisaic Judaism - in some respects: the ancestor of comtemporary Judaism. This in turn will allow for accusations of hypocrisy and deicide. Such immature conceit is contradictory to elementary Christian values. The long tradition of pointing fingers and blaming others for Christ's death misses the point of the Gospel, which now even scholars must remind, is "love one another."
Thus the scholarly study of Religion is no less important than Faith, even in a theological system in which salvation is by Faith alone. Incorrect understanding is an obstacle to Faith: the one who simply believes believes in nothing, or believes in something wrong. An all-forgiving Deity will necessarily overlook such trespasses made in His Name, but with regards to living the Faith - that is, making religious experience meaningful in the here and now; the only way in which Faith becomes manifest to us - an open mind is of critical importance.
Homework: Think critically about at least one thing you do or believe that doesn't make sense.
Tune du jour: Try klezmer. Yeah, I'm feeling Jewish.


No comments
Post a Comment