It could very well be that the difference between proper mental hygiene and hysteria is mostly a matter of personal determination.
When I feel bad about myself or the world, I indulge in docile self-deprecation and sullen, fatalistic piety. Others prefer to slash their wrists open. From the perspective of pure rationality, the latter option - albeit not very practical for reasons of comfort - is not any less likely to improve the condition of the sufferer than the former. Indulgence of any sort is necessarily a kind of diversion - it is frequently part of the condition, and hardly ever its solution. In this instance of reasoning it would be best to consider every individual's sanity as a matter of degree, and to realize that on a personal level, the difference between "motivation" and "obsession" is not a very substantial one.
Civilization, therefore, is only skin-deep, and its justification is not found in the distant ether of transcendental logic. A correct evaluation of our social institutions states that whatever culture unites us - according to and in spite of our own opinions - can only be conceived in terms of preter-rational phenomena. At the foundation of our collective belief systems are certain assumptions that bear the arbitrariness of the a priori without even the pretense of finding support in empirical or deductive logic. This is evident upon the contemplation of a society's ultimate concern. Within Western societies, the most basic imperative is (one assumes) the search for "the greater good of the whole" - but that "greater good" is so ill-defined as to confuse rather than direct the social force. Without a normative definition of happiness, civilzations are left to wander aimlessly in their collective madness, the fruit of their own alienation from those parts of themselves which constantly attempt to define and refine meaning. If the ideal of the "greater good of the whole" were to be replaced by something more straightforward, tangible, and imminently consequential, perhaps a greater part of the social force could thus be harnessed and much morbid deviation would be avoided.
Whereas the "diseased" aspect of insanity lies not in the lack of social sanction of the patient's behaviour but rather in the inherently grievous nature of the condition (of which lack of social sanction is partly the cause) it is nonetheless useful to remind ourselves that our deranged brethren suffer predominantly because of what we collectively put into their minds. Even in the worst states of confusion the psychiatric patient will nonetheless shape and react to his/her suffering according to the language of his/her cultural matrix. It must be recognized that even denial or opposition to certain social realities is grounded in the cultural matrix. Delirium is alienation - and meaninglessness, and certainly pain - but it is not alienation from that social force, that consensus which we consider to be the proper order of things. It is alienation within that order.
My point here is that Chaos is neither the problem nor its source. Our notions of order - logical or otherwise, are superficial, whereas the pain of madness is rooted much deeper. Madness expresses itself in confusion, but it is confusion only insofar as throwing a wrench in the cogs of the working machine is disorder. Ultimately it is the society that is responsible for building a machine that doesn't know how to cope with the wrench.
When I feel bad about myself or the world, I indulge in docile self-deprecation and sullen, fatalistic piety. Others prefer to slash their wrists open. From the perspective of pure rationality, the latter option - albeit not very practical for reasons of comfort - is not any less likely to improve the condition of the sufferer than the former. Indulgence of any sort is necessarily a kind of diversion - it is frequently part of the condition, and hardly ever its solution. In this instance of reasoning it would be best to consider every individual's sanity as a matter of degree, and to realize that on a personal level, the difference between "motivation" and "obsession" is not a very substantial one.
Civilization, therefore, is only skin-deep, and its justification is not found in the distant ether of transcendental logic. A correct evaluation of our social institutions states that whatever culture unites us - according to and in spite of our own opinions - can only be conceived in terms of preter-rational phenomena. At the foundation of our collective belief systems are certain assumptions that bear the arbitrariness of the a priori without even the pretense of finding support in empirical or deductive logic. This is evident upon the contemplation of a society's ultimate concern. Within Western societies, the most basic imperative is (one assumes) the search for "the greater good of the whole" - but that "greater good" is so ill-defined as to confuse rather than direct the social force. Without a normative definition of happiness, civilzations are left to wander aimlessly in their collective madness, the fruit of their own alienation from those parts of themselves which constantly attempt to define and refine meaning. If the ideal of the "greater good of the whole" were to be replaced by something more straightforward, tangible, and imminently consequential, perhaps a greater part of the social force could thus be harnessed and much morbid deviation would be avoided.
Whereas the "diseased" aspect of insanity lies not in the lack of social sanction of the patient's behaviour but rather in the inherently grievous nature of the condition (of which lack of social sanction is partly the cause) it is nonetheless useful to remind ourselves that our deranged brethren suffer predominantly because of what we collectively put into their minds. Even in the worst states of confusion the psychiatric patient will nonetheless shape and react to his/her suffering according to the language of his/her cultural matrix. It must be recognized that even denial or opposition to certain social realities is grounded in the cultural matrix. Delirium is alienation - and meaninglessness, and certainly pain - but it is not alienation from that social force, that consensus which we consider to be the proper order of things. It is alienation within that order.
My point here is that Chaos is neither the problem nor its source. Our notions of order - logical or otherwise, are superficial, whereas the pain of madness is rooted much deeper. Madness expresses itself in confusion, but it is confusion only insofar as throwing a wrench in the cogs of the working machine is disorder. Ultimately it is the society that is responsible for building a machine that doesn't know how to cope with the wrench.


No comments
Post a Comment