Pages

Saturday, 1 October 2005

Thoughts on Being Sorry


I used to believe in Man's unconditioned ability to feel sorry. The problem with this notion is that genuine compassion & pity are in fact worlds apart, & though I've been aware of the philosophical significance of this fundamental difference for quite some time, I've only recently begun to see its true implications. Man's potential for sympathy is indeed limitless, & his well of pity unfathomably deep, but wasting such gifts too indiscriminately takes away from their meaning. In pitying everything, including oneself, Man becomes an ungrateful, humourless thing – Creation assumes an unwholesome, pitiable tone – & nothing could distance anyone further away from redemption & happiness. The epitome of pity is like an unquenchable thirst, a thirst that thirsts for itself & calls for nothing else, except perhaps for destruction.

Thus pity must be spent sparingly. I am not happy with this conclusion, but this is probably the difference between pity & compassion: a recognition of the ontological limitations on the human condition with regards to sympathy. Feeling sorry that the entire world cannot, in fact, benefit from my limitless supply of pity may be the first step towards realistic & insightful action.

The critical conclusion of this reflection is that, whereas all people are entitled to human sympathy (all people have intrinsic value) all human actions do not necessarily deserve the same treatment. We cannot afford to have too narrow a focus in our expressions of pity: sympathy with foolishness is at best a form of condescension & at worst tacit approval of those very deeds that bring about suffering.

Concretely this means I ought not to feel sorry for those who wallow in their misery as though it had a rich aesthetic quality. I cannot sit there, smile & nod (or pretend the world is a horrible place) only to sympathize with the deluded. That in itself is sad in a way, but fortunately there are better alternatives.

In these respects I owe a lot of people an apology for my own lack of trust in the world, & in myself. I do realize the blog is a rather artificial media to publish such confessions, but it is the most readily available one, & the most opened to discussion.

. . .

Tune du jour: King Crimson's Confusion.

No comments

Post a Comment